Does Insurance Go Up After Hitting a Deer? A Comprehensive Guide to Understanding the Cost

Driving on the highway can be a hazardous experience, especially during fall and winter months when deer are more active. With over 1 million deer-vehicle collisions each year, hitting a deer is a common and often costly occurrence for drivers. One of the biggest questions people have after their encounter is whether or not their insurance will go up.

While it can be frustrating to experience a collision with a deer, it’s important to understand the potential financial repercussions as well. Hitting a deer can cause significant damage to your vehicle, which can result in costly repairs. Additionally, if you live in an area where deer are prevalent, your chances of hitting one increase, ultimately affecting your insurance rates.

There are several factors that insurance companies consider when determining whether or not your rates will increase after hitting a deer. These can include the extent of damage to your vehicle, your history of claims, and the specific insurance policy you have. It’s important to understand how your insurance company handles these situations to ensure that you’re prepared in the event of a collision with a deer. So, does insurance go up after hitting a deer? Let’s find out.

Car insurance coverage for animal collisions

Driving can be unpredictable, and unexpected situations like hitting an animal on the road can be unnerving. Not only can hitting an animal be dangerous, but it can also result in significant damage to both the vehicle and the animal. When it comes to auto insurance coverage for animal collisions, there are a few things to know.

  • Collision Coverage: Collision coverage is typically an optional add-on to a car insurance policy. This coverage helps pay for damage to your vehicle resulting from a collision with another vehicle or an object. In cases of hitting an animal, collision coverage may cover the cost of repairs. However, the coverage is not automatically included in your policy, and it is essential to check with your insurance provider to ensure you have the coverage.
  • Comprehensive Coverage: Comprehensive coverage helps pay for damage to your vehicle resulting from non-collision incidents, such as theft, vandalism, weather events, and yes, hitting an animal. Comprehensive coverage is also an optional add-on to a car insurance policy, and it is essential to check if your policy includes this coverage.
  • Deductible: The deductible is the amount you must pay out of pocket before the insurance coverage kicks in. So, if you have a $500 deductible and the damage to your vehicle amounts to $2,000, you would pay $500, and your insurance would cover the remaining $1,500. It is crucial to check your policy for your deductible amount and ensure that it is affordable for your budget and anticipated repair costs.

It’s worth noting that hitting an animal may not result in an increase in insurance premiums as it is usually considered a comprehensive claim, viewed differently than a collision with another vehicle. However, it is essential to check with your insurance provider as some may classify it as a collision and, therefore, increase your premiums.

In summary, auto insurance coverage for animal collisions may be included under collision coverage or comprehensive coverage, depending on your policy. Checking with your insurance provider to confirm your coverage and deductible is essential. Hitting an animal on the road may not necessarily result in a premium increase, but it is always important to verify with your insurance provider.

Raising deductibles in response to animal collisions

Animal collisions can often lead to an increase in your insurance premiums since insurers view it as a risk for accidents. One option to mitigate higher insurance costs is to raise your deductible: the amount you must pay out of pocket before your insurance kicks in. By raising your deductible, you can lower your insurance rates and potentially save money in the long run.

  • Consider how much you can afford to pay out of pocket before raising your deductible. While a higher deductible can save you money on premiums, it also means you’re responsible for a higher amount if you hit a deer or other animal.
  • Ask your insurance provider about animal collision coverage. Some policies may include specific coverage for animal collisions, while others may require a higher deductible for these types of accidents.
  • If you live in an area with a higher risk of animal collisions, such as near a forest or rural area, it may be worth considering higher deductibles to offset potential insurance costs.

Here is a breakdown of how increasing your deductible can impact your insurance rates:

Deductible Amount Collision Premium Increase
$500 10%-12%
$1,000 20%-25%
$2,000 30%-40%

Keep in mind that each insurance provider may have different rates and policies, so it’s always best to do your research and carefully consider your options before making a decision.

The Impact of an Animal Collision on Your Driving Record

If you hit a deer with your car, one of your biggest concerns may be what it means for your insurance rates. Unfortunately, hitting a deer can indeed raise your insurance rates, as it counts as an at-fault collision. Let’s take a closer look at the impact of an animal collision on your driving record.

  • At-Fault Collision: When you hit a deer or any other animal, it’s considered an at-fault collision. This means that you, as the driver, were deemed responsible for the accident. As a result, your insurance rates may increase. The extent of the increase will depend on your specific policy and the severity of the collision.
  • Claim Filing: If you file an insurance claim after hitting a deer, you will see an impact on your driving record. The collision will be noted in your claims history, which is a factor that insurers consider when determining your rates. Even if you don’t file a claim, your insurance company may still find out about the collision through police reports or other third-party sources.
  • Deductibles and Coverage: The financial impact of hitting a deer will also depend on your policy’s deductible and coverage. If your collision coverage has a high deductible, you may end up paying a significant portion of the repair costs out of pocket. On the other hand, if you have comprehensive coverage, which covers non-collision incidents like hitting an animal, you may have a lower deductible and less out-of-pocket costs.

In addition to the financial impact, an animal collision can also have other effects on your driving record. For example, if the collision resulted in severe damage or injury, you may receive points on your license or even have it suspended. Additionally, if you have a history of other traffic violations or accidents, an animal collision may compound the negative impact on your driving record.

Effect on Driving Record Impact
At-Fault Collision Increase in insurance rates
Claims History Noted in claims history, may impact rates
Comprehensive Coverage Lower deductible, less out-of-pocket costs
Points on License Possible for severe damage or injury

In summary, hitting an animal with your car can have a variety of impacts on your driving record, including increased insurance rates, noted claims history, and potential points on your license. To mitigate the financial impact, it is important to review your insurance policy and understand your coverage and deductibles. Additionally, staying alert and practicing safe driving habits can help prevent animal collisions and keep you and your passengers safe on the road.

Ways to prevent animal collisions while driving

Animal collisions while driving are not uncommon, especially in rural and wooded areas. They not only cause damage to your vehicle but can also result in serious injury or even death. Here are some ways to prevent animal collisions while driving:

  • Be alert: The first thing you need to do to prevent animal collisions while driving is to be alert. Keep your eyes peeled for any animals crossing the road, especially during dawn and dusk when wildlife is the most active.
  • Use your high beams: When driving in an area with a high risk of animal collisions, use your high beams to increase your visibility. This will help you spot animals from a greater distance, giving you more time to react.
  • Slow down: If you see an animal on the road, slow down immediately. This will give you more time to react if the animal suddenly darts across the road.

However, even if you follow all the above ways, there is always a chance of hitting an animal while driving. Here’s a table showing the likelihood of hitting various animals while driving in the US:

Animal Likelihood of hitting per year
Deer 1 in 169
Elk 1 in 721
Mooses 1 in 721
Bear 1 in 2,868

Knowing the likelihood of hitting an animal while driving can help you prepare for the worst and take proactive measures like purchasing insurance. Please note that insurance rates may go up if you hit an animal, and it is always best to check with your insurance provider beforehand.

The cost of repairing a car after hitting a deer

One of the biggest concerns for drivers after hitting a deer is the cost of repairing their vehicle. The final bill can vary widely depending on various factors such as the damage sustained by the car, the parts that need replacement, and the level of insurance coverage that a driver has purchased.

  • Bodywork: The cost of repairing body damage can range from a few hundred dollars to well over a thousand dollars. This depends on the extent of the damage, as well as the type and make of the vehicle. Additionally, the cost of bodywork can go up if the deer’s antlers have punctured through the hood or radiator.
  • Headlights and Taillights: The cost of replacing headlights or taillights can vary depending on whether the owner replaces it themselves or it is done by a professional auto body technician. The cost of replacing a headlight usually ranges from $200-$500, while taillight replacements can cost between $200-$400.
  • Windshields: Replacing a cracked windshield could cost between $200 and $500, depending on the type of windshield, the make of the vehicle, and where the replacement is carried out. Repairing a small crack may cost much less.

It is also important to note that these costs could be greatly reduced if the driver has comprehensive car insurance coverage. With the right policy, the cost of repairing a vehicle can come down significantly. If you have comprehensive coverage, it covers the resulting damage caused to your car, up to the vehicle’s actual cash value, less your deductible. If you are not insured, repairing the damage can be very costly.

In conclusion, hitting a deer can be an unfortunate event for drivers, but the cost of repairing your car after the accident should not be prohibitive for most drivers. If you have insurance, the coverage cost could be significantly reduced, and if not, the cost could most likely be covered through financing options offered by auto-body repair shops or mentioned in the deer collision report provided by police. It is important to avoid any chances of colliding with deer by taking extra precautions when traveling on roads and to remember to always use your seatbelt.

For more information on the cost of repairing a vehicle after hitting a deer, check out the table below that breaks down some of the common costs of repairs a driver might incur:

Vehicle Part Repair Cost Range
Bodywork $300-$1500
Headlights $200-$500
Taillights $200-$400
Windshield $200-$500

Coping with the Emotional Aftermath of an Animal Collision


Dealing with the aftermath of a car accident with a deer, or any animal, not only involves financial and physical pain, but also emotional distress and trauma. You may find yourself struggling to cope with feelings such as guilt, anxiety, fear, and even sadness. Here are some ways to help you get through this challenging time:

  • Seek Support: It is important to talk to someone about your emotions after an animal collision. Reach out to a friend, family member, or a professional counselor. They can provide a listening ear and help you process your feelings.
  • Practice Self-Care: Your well-being is crucial after a car accident with an animal. Allow yourself to rest, eat healthy, exercise, and engage in activities that bring you joy and relaxation.
  • Acknowledge the Experience: Ignoring or denying the emotional impact of an animal collision can make your feelings more intense and last longer. Acknowledge the experience and give yourself permission to feel.

Remember that it is normal to experience emotional distress after an animal collision. It does not make you weak or vulnerable. Acknowledge your emotions, reach out for support, and allow yourself to heal.

Additionally, if you feel that your emotions are affecting your daily life, seek professional help. A mental health professional can help you process your feelings and develop coping strategies.

Here are a few quotes or affirmations to help you overcome your emotional challenges:

Quote Affirmation
“The strongest people are not those who show strength in front of us but those who win battles we know nothing about.” “I am strong enough to overcome my emotional challenges.”
“I can’t control everything in my life, but I can control how I react to it.” “I choose to react positively to my emotions.”

Coping with the emotional aftermath of an animal collision is crucial for your well-being. Take care of yourself, reach out for support, and remember that your feelings are valid.

Comparing different insurance companies’ policies on animal collisions

One of the most frequent questions asked by drivers involved in animal collisions is whether or not their insurance rates will increase after making a claim. The answer is not straightforward, as each insurer has different policies and coverage options. However, we can compare several insurance companies’ policies to give you a better idea of what to expect.

Insurers with Comprehensive Coverage

  • State Farm: According to their website, State Farm’s comprehensive coverage may provide protection against animal collisions. They do not mention a rate increase due to a deer collision, but note that a driver’s rates may increase for other reasons, such as a change in driving record or location.
  • Geico: Geico’s comprehensive coverage usually covers animal collisions without rate increases. However, they note that rates may still increase due to other factors, such as the severity of the accident or the type of vehicle involved.
  • Allstate: Allstate’s comprehensive coverage may cover animal collisions without a rate increase. Like the other insurers, Allstate notes that rates may still increase due to other factors, such as the frequency and severity of claims.

Insurers without Comprehensive Coverage

Some insurers may not offer comprehensive coverage at all, making it more difficult to file a claim for an animal collision. In these cases, drivers may need to take extra precautions on the road to avoid animal collisions and other types of accidents, as there may not be any financial protection available.

Factors that Affect Rate Increases

While some insurers may not raise rates for animal collisions, they may still consider other factors when determining rates. These factors include:

  • The severity of the damage: if the collision caused significant damage or injury, insurers may be more likely to increase rates
  • The frequency of claims: if a driver has filed multiple claims in a short period of time, insurers may view them as a higher risk and raise rates accordingly
  • The driver’s location: insurers may raise rates based on location, as certain areas may have higher rates of animal collisions

Conclusion

Ultimately, every insurer has different policies and coverage options, so it’s important to check with your specific insurance company to understand exactly what to expect after an animal collision. While some insurers may not raise rates for animal collisions, other factors such as the severity of damage and location may still impact rates. Drivers should always prioritize safety on the road and take measures to avoid animal collisions as much as possible.

Insurance Company Comprehensive Coverage for Animal Collisions? Rate Increase for Deer Collision?
State Farm Yes Not specified
Geico Usually May increase for other reasons
Allstate Yes Not specified

Does Insurance Go Up After Hitting a Deer? FAQs

Q: Will my insurance rates increase if I hit a deer?
A: It depends on the circumstances. If you have comprehensive coverage, hitting a deer is typically covered and should not result in an increase in your rates. However, if you file a claim and it is determined that you were at fault or contributed to the accident, your rates may increase.

Q: Do I need to report hitting a deer to my insurance company?
A: Yes, it is important to report any accident, including hitting a deer, to your insurance company as soon as possible. Not reporting the accident could lead to complications with your coverage.

Q: How much will my rates increase?
A: The amount that your rates will increase after hitting a deer depends on various factors, such as your driving record, the severity of the accident, and your insurance company’s policies regarding accidents.

Q: Is there anything I can do to prevent my rates from increasing?
A: You may be able to avoid an increase in your rates by choosing not to file a claim and paying for repairs out of pocket. Additionally, taking a defensive driving course or improving your driving habits may demonstrate to your insurance company that you are a responsible driver.

Closing Thoughts

Thank you for reading our article on whether insurance rates go up after hitting a deer. It’s important to remember that every insurance company has different policies and every situation is different. If you find yourself in an accident involving a deer, be sure to report it to your insurance company and discuss your options. And don’t forget to drive carefully on those winding country roads! We hope you’ll visit us again for more tips on navigating the world of insurance.